3.2. Connectivity

Complementary to the \(n\)-truncated morphisms are the \(n\)-connected morphisms. Truncated morphisms have no homotopy above degree \(n\), while connected morphisms become terminal after discarding homotopy above degree \(n\). We formulate this using relative truncation, identify the resulting orthogonality relation, and obtain the connected–truncated factorization system.

Definition 3.16.

Let \(T\) be a topos, and let \(n \geq -2\).

  • We say that \(X \in T\) is \(n\)-connected if \(\tau_n X = *\).

  • We say \(f \colon X \to Y\) is \(n\)-connected if it is \(n\)-connected in \(T_{/Y}\).

We denote by \(T^{\geq n+1}\) the full subcategory of \(T\) spanned by the \(n\)-connected objects.

Warning 3.17.

In the classical algebraic topology literature, what we call an \(n\)-connected morphism is often called \((n-1)\)-connected. Our indexing is chosen so that \(n\)-connected and \(n\)-truncated morphisms form complementary classes with the same index, and so that the definition applies unchanged in every slice topos.

Note that every object is \((-2)\)-connected. The universal property of relative truncation gives the complementary orthogonality description. Namely, \(f\colon X \to Y\) is \(n\)-connected if and only if for every solid commutative diagram of the form

Commutative diagram generated from the LaTeX source

where \(g\) is \(n\)-truncated, the anima of diagonal fillers is contractible. Indeed, this anima is the fiber of

\[\Hom_{/Y}(Y,U) \longrightarrow \Hom_{/Y}(X,U)\]

over the given map \(X \to U\). Since \(U \to Y\) is \(n\)-truncated, the universal property of \(\tau_n(X/Y)\) identifies the target with \(\Hom_{/Y}(\tau_n(X/Y),U)\). Thus the filler animae are contractible for all such \(U\) precisely when the map \(\tau_n(X/Y) \to Y\) induces equivalences into every \(n\)-truncated object. Since both its source and target are \(n\)-truncated in \(T_{/Y}\), Yoneda identifies this condition with \(\tau_n(X/Y) \iso Y\).

Proposition 3.18.

Let \(T\) be a topos.

  1. The pair (\(n\)-connected, \(n\)-truncated) forms a factorization system on \(T\).

  2. The \(n\)-connected maps are stable under base change.

  3. A map \(f\colon X \to Y\) is \(n\)-connected if and only if the functor \(f^*\colon (T_{/Y})_{\leq n} \to (T_{/X})_{\leq n}\) is fully faithful.

Proof
(1) We first show that any map \(f\colon X \to Y\) factors as an \(n\)-connected map followed by an \(n\)-truncated map. Let \(X_n := \tau_n(X/Y)\) be the \(n\)-truncation of \(X \in T_{/Y}\). The map \(X_n \to Y\) is \(n\)-truncated by definition.To show that \(X \to X_n\) is \(n\)-connected, consider any \(n\)-truncated morphism \(U \to X_n\). We must show that the map
\[\Hom_{/X_n}(X_n,U) \to \Hom_{/X_n}(X,U)\]
is an equivalence. Since \(T_{/X_n} \simeq (T_{/Y})_{/X_n}\), this map is induced on vertical fibers in the following diagram of Hom animae in \(T_{/Y}\):
Commutative diagram generated from the LaTeX source
Since \(U\) and \(X_n\) are \(n\)-truncated objects in \(T_{/Y}\), the universal property of \(X_n = \tau_n(X/Y) \in T_{/Y}\) guarantees that both horizontal maps are equivalences. Thus the induced map on fibers is also an equivalence.Next, we show that any \(n\)-connected map \(f\colon X \to Y\) is left orthogonal to any \(n\)-truncated map \(g\colon W \to Z\). We must show that the anima of diagonal fillers in any commutative square
Commutative diagram generated from the LaTeX source
is contractible. Since \(n\)-truncated maps are closed under base change, we may replace \(g\) by the projection \(W \times_Z Y \to Y\). This reduces the problem to finding diagonal fillers in the commutative square:
Commutative diagram generated from the LaTeX source
The anima of such diagonal fillers is contractible by \(n\)-connectedness of \(f\). We have therefore constructed the required factorization and proved orthogonality, which are exactly the two conditions in Definition A.2.(2) Consider a pullback square
Commutative diagram generated from the LaTeX source
By Corollary 3.10, we have \(\tau_n(X'/Y') \cong g^*\tau_n(X/Y)\). If \(f\) is \(n\)-connected, then \(\tau_n(X/Y) = Y\), so \(\tau_n(X'/Y') = Y'\). Hence \(f'\) is also \(n\)-connected.(3) We need to show that \(f\) is \(n\)-connected if and only if for each two \(n\)-truncated maps \(Z \to Y\) and \(Z' \to Y\), the induced map
\[f^*\colon \Hom_{/Y}(Z,Z') \to \Hom_{/X}(X \times_Y Z, X \times_Y Z')\]
is an equivalence. By the universal property of \(X \times_Y Z'\), the latter is equivalent to the condition that composition with the projection \(X \times_Y Z \to Z\) induces an equivalence
\[\Hom_{/Y}(Z,Z') \iso \Hom_{/Y}(X \times_Y Z, Z').\]
In other words, we have to show that \(f\) is \(n\)-connected if and only if the map \(X \times_Y Z \to Z\) is left orthogonal to every \(n\)-truncated map \(Z' \to Y\). If \(f\) is \(n\)-connected, this follows from parts (1) and (2), since \(X \times_Y Z \to Z\) is a base change of \(f\). Conversely, take \(Z=Y\). The resulting orthogonality condition says that \(f\) is left orthogonal to every \(n\)-truncated map over \(Y\), which is equivalent to \(n\)-connectedness by the characterization above.

Lemma 3.19.

Consider a pullback square in a topos

Commutative diagram generated from the LaTeX source

in which \(g\) is an effective epimorphism. Then, for every \(n \geq -2\), the morphism \(f\) is \(n\)-truncated (resp. \(n\)-connected) if and only if \(f'\) is \(n\)-truncated (resp. \(n\)-connected).

Proof
Both properties are preserved by arbitrary base change, by Lemma 3.5 and Proposition 3.18. We prove the converses.For truncatedness, argue by induction on \(n\). If \(n=-2\), the claim says that an isomorphism can be detected after pullback along an effective epimorphism, which follows from Lemma 2.29. For \(n\geq -1\), the diagonal of \(f'\) is obtained from the diagonal of \(f\) by base change along the effective epimorphism
\[X'\times_{Y'}X' \longrightarrow X\times_YX.\]
The induction hypothesis therefore shows that \(\Delta_f\) is \((n-1)\)-truncated whenever \(\Delta_{f'}\) is.For connectedness, Corollary 3.10 gives an isomorphism
\[\tau_n(X'/Y') \cong g^*\tau_n(X/Y).\]
If \(f'\) is \(n\)-connected, the pullback of \(\tau_n(X/Y)\to Y\) along \(g\) is therefore an isomorphism. Pullback along \(g\) is conservative by Lemma 2.29, so \(\tau_n(X/Y)\to Y\) is itself an isomorphism. Thus \(f\) is \(n\)-connected.

Corollary 3.20.

A morphism is \((-1)\)-connected if and only if it is an effective epimorphism.

Proof
Both the \((-1)\)-connected maps as well as the effective epimorphisms are characterized as the morphisms that are left orthogonal to the monomorphisms/(-1)-truncated maps.

Corollary 3.21.

Every pointed object \(X \in T_*\) is \((-1)\)-connected.

Proof
A basepoint \(x\colon * \to X\) determines a section of the map \(X \to *\), which by Lemma 2.38 implies that \(X \to *\) is an effective epimorphism, hence \((-1)\)-connected.